Data Platform Evolution: Four-Tier AWS Architecture Framework

A progressive approach to building enterprise data capabilities

Introduction

This framework presents four progressive tiers of data platform maturity on AWS, focusing on the evolution from basic storage to comprehensive enterprise data warehousing. Each tier represents a distinct level of data management capability, complexity, and cost - without the added complexity of machine learning components. This approach allows organizations to incrementally build their data platform according to their current needs and future growth plans.

Tier 1 Basic Data Storage Foundation

Core Components
  • Amazon S3 (Standard or Intelligent-Tiering)
  • Basic folder structure maintained by application teams
  • Minimal data dictionary (documentation only)
Data Model Approach
  • Application-driven schemas
  • Basic JSON/CSV formats pushed directly by application teams
  • No central data modeling governance
  • Siloed data definitions
Team Requirements
  • Size: 1-2 developers with part-time data responsibilities
  • Skills: Basic AWS S3 knowledge, application data exports
  • Structure: Managed by existing development teams
  • Est. Annual Team Cost: $40,000-$100,000 (part-time allocation)
Infrastructure Costs
  • S3 storage: $0.023-$0.03 per GB/month
  • Minimal data transfer fees
  • Est. Monthly Infrastructure: $300-$2,000 for 5-10TB
Business Value
  • Centralized storage location for application data
  • Cost-effective data persistence
  • Reliable backup and reference data availability
  • Foundational step toward data-driven decision making
Limitations
  • No unified data model
  • Data silos with inconsistent definitions
  • Limited data discovery capabilities
  • Difficult to perform cross-application analysis
  • Heavy reliance on application teams for data understanding

Tier 2 Emergent Lakehouse Foundation

Core Components
  • Amazon S3 for storage with standardized partitioning
  • AWS Glue Data Catalog for metadata management
  • Amazon Athena for SQL-based queries
  • Basic data flow automation (AWS Glue or simple ETL scripts)
Data Model Approach
  • Emerging common data dictionary
  • Standardized file formats (Parquet/ORC)
  • Basic data domains identified
  • Initial data transformation processes
Team Requirements
  • Size: 2-3 specialists (1 full-time data engineer, part-time analyst support)
  • Skills: S3, Glue, Athena, SQL, basic data modeling
  • Structure: Dedicated data engineer with part-time support
  • Est. Annual Team Cost: $150,000-$250,000
Infrastructure Costs
  • S3 storage: $0.023-$0.03 per GB/month
  • Glue Data Catalog: Free tier + $1 per 100,000 objects beyond 1M
  • Athena: $5 per TB scanned
  • Est. Monthly Infrastructure: $1,000-$4,000 for moderate usage
Business Value
  • Self-service SQL access for analysts
  • Improved data discoverability
  • Ability to join data across applications
  • Foundation for data governance
  • More consistent data transformation processes
Limitations
  • Incomplete data model standardization
  • Limited business context in data definitions
  • Basic data quality controls only
  • Limited performance for complex analytical queries
  • Minimal data lineage tracking

Tier 3 Enterprise Data Model Platform

Core Components
  • Amazon S3 for storage
  • AWS Glue Data Catalog with enhanced metadata
  • AWS Glue ETL or dbt for transformation logic
  • Amazon Redshift (right-sized) or Athena with optimization
  • AWS Lake Formation for governance
Data Model Approach
  • Formalized data design process
  • Enterprise data modeling with business definitions
  • Dimensional modeling for analytical use cases
  • Data stewardship program implementation
  • Data quality framework with validation rules
Team Requirements
  • Size: 4-6 specialists (2-3 data engineers, 1-2 data analysts, 1 data architect)
  • Skills: Data modeling, ETL pipelines, SQL optimization, data governance
  • Structure: Dedicated data team with enterprise modeling expertise
  • Est. Annual Team Cost: $400,000-$700,000
Infrastructure Costs
  • S3 storage: $0.023-$0.03 per GB/month
  • Glue ETL: $0.44 per DPU-hour
  • Redshift: $0.25-$3.26 per DC2/RA3 node-hour
  • Lake Formation: No additional cost beyond underlying services
  • Est. Monthly Infrastructure: $3,000-$15,000 depending on workload
Business Value
  • Business-aligned data definitions
  • Consistent analytical environment
  • Improved query performance for business reporting
  • Clear data lineage and ownership
  • Enhanced data quality and reliability
  • Simplified data access for business users
Limitations
  • Requires significant data modeling expertise
  • More complex to implement and maintain
  • Higher operational overhead
  • Change management challenges with business stakeholders

Tier 4 Enterprise Data Warehouse & BI Platform

Core Components
  • Modern data warehouse (Redshift Serverless/Provisioned)
  • Comprehensive ETL/ELT framework with orchestration
  • Data quality monitoring and alerting
  • Advanced data governance tools
  • Semantic layer for business definitions
  • Fully integrated BI tooling with self-service capabilities
  • Data mesh/domain-oriented design principles
Data Model Approach
  • Complete enterprise data model
  • Business glossary with standardized terminology
  • Advanced dimensional and data vault modeling
  • Automated data quality enforcement
  • Domain-specific data products
  • Cross-domain data standards
Team Requirements
  • Size: 8-12 specialists (3-4 data engineers, 2-3 data architects, 2-3 BI developers, 1-2 data governance specialists)
  • Skills: Advanced data modeling, warehouse optimization, data quality frameworks, governance implementation
  • Structure: Full data organization with specialized teams
  • Est. Annual Team Cost: $800,000-$1,500,000
Infrastructure Costs
  • Redshift Serverless: $0.36-$1.086 per RPU-hour
  • S3 storage with advanced lifecycle policies
  • ETL/Orchestration tools: AWS Glue, Step Functions
  • Data governance and quality tools
  • Est. Monthly Infrastructure: $10,000-$50,000 for enterprise workloads
Business Value
  • Enterprise-grade reliability and performance
  • Comprehensive self-service BI capabilities
  • Trusted single source of truth for business metrics
  • Automated data quality and governance
  • Business semantics embedded in data platform
  • Scalable approach to cross-functional analytics
Limitations
  • Significant implementation complexity
  • High specialized skill requirements
  • Substantial change management challenges
  • Ongoing maintenance overhead
  • Risk of over-engineering

Total Cost of Ownership

Annual Estimates

Cost Category Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 4
Team Costs $40K-$100K $150K-$250K $400K-$700K $800K-$1.5M
Infrastructure $4K-$24K $12K-$48K $36K-$180K $120K-$600K
Tools & Support $5K-$10K $15K-$30K $50K-$100K $100K-$250K
Total Annual TCO $49K-$134K $177K-$328K $486K-$980K $1.02M-$2.35M

Implementation Timeline

Architecture Tier Design Phase Initial Implementation Business Adoption
Tier 1: Basic Storage 2-4 weeks 1-2 months 1-2 months
Tier 2: Emergent Lakehouse 1-2 months 2-3 months 3-4 months
Tier 3: Enterprise Data Model 3-6 months 4-6 months 6-9 months
Tier 4: Enterprise DWH & BI 4-8 months 6-10 months 9-12 months

Key Decision Factors

  1. Data Complexity: The variety and complexity of data sources and business domains
  2. Analytical Maturity: The sophistication of required business analytics
  3. Organizational Scale: The size of the organization and diversity of stakeholders
  4. Performance Requirements: Query response times and concurrency needs
  5. Governance Requirements: Regulatory compliance and data sensitivity
  6. Business Alignment: Level of standardization needed for business definitions
  7. Available Expertise: Current team capabilities and recruitment potential
  8. Growth Trajectory: Anticipated data volume and analytical complexity increase

Implementation Recommendations

  1. Prioritize Business Value: Focus initial efforts on high-value data domains
  2. Design for Incremental Growth: Architect solutions that can evolve across tiers
  3. Balance Technical and Business Needs: Ensure data modeling reflects business requirements
  4. Invest in Data Literacy: Train business users on data concepts and self-service tools
  5. Document from Day One: Maintain comprehensive metadata even in early tiers
  6. Establish Data Ownership: Define clear data stewardship roles at every stage
  7. Validate Requirements Carefully: Ensure technical solutions match actual analytical needs
  8. Consider Implementation Partners: Leverage external expertise for critical design phases

Tier Evolution Pathway

The most effective approach for most organizations is to evolve through these tiers sequentially:

  1. Establish the Foundation (Tier 1): Centralize application data in a consistent S3 environment
  2. Enable Basic Analytics (Tier 2): Implement data catalog and query capabilities
  3. Standardize Enterprise Models (Tier 3): Develop formal data modeling and governance
  4. Optimize for Business Consumption (Tier 4): Build the comprehensive DWH and BI platform

Organizations should resist the temptation to skip tiers, as each level builds essential capabilities and organizational maturity needed for subsequent stages. The timeline for evolution will vary based on organizational needs, but rushing implementation typically leads to adoption challenges.

Back to Use Case Hype Cycle